The Hello Bar is a simple web toolbar that engages users and communicates a call to action.

Guest Post: Writing A New Story for Women by Ronna Detrick

by Desiree Adaway on March 16, 2010

 I help to change people’s perception of the poor & marginalized -and in doing that help people change their perceptions of themselves. My writings  here are always based in reality and experience-education and action are my buzz words.  I like to use this space  to tell the truth and show unvarnished pictures of the world around us. Its how I think, and honestly its my most authentic voice.  Today  I  am proud  to step away from my “voice” and to utilize this space  to highlight the voice of another “Truth Teller”.  Her voice is powerful and moved me. I hope it does the same for you.

I want justice to be so pervasive that it will be taken for granted, just as injustice is taken for granted today. ~Gloria Macpagal Arroyo

The issue of social justice for women makes my heart start racing. I want to stand up and scream for things to change. They have to, right? Women continue to know levels of hardship and harm that defy my comprehension: objectification, inequity, discrimination, domestic violence, sexual trafficking. How can such continue, be propagated, and even allowed without a collective battle-stance against such realities?  Social justice is defined as “the distribution of advantages and disadvantages within a society.” For me, that (mis)distribution emerges directly from our held perspectives and beliefs; the lenses through which we view and understand everything: religion, philosophy, politics, ethics, social constructs. Most of the time these lenses go unnamed and unacknowledged, thus becoming match-to-flame for social justice’s absence – again and ongoing.

How did we get here? And more importantly, how are we to make headway, restore hope, or ever tilt the scales within our world? Can we really expect such deeply-entrenched perspectives and beliefs to change, thereby enabling new ones?

 

After I sit back down and let my pulse slow, I begin to ask questions and allow my mind to wander into stories and texts that have shaped, if not contributed to and created, our current realities. And though disturbing, I begin to feel a spark of hope. Here’s why: I believe that social justice can and will (at least in part) be powerfully present when we look back, reimagine, and reinterpret our past; when we name and acknowledge our interpretive lenses; when we change our foundational perspectives and beliefs. Instead of letting history repeat itself, we create a new future. We write a new story.

 When I look back I often go to old, old narratives; sacred texts that have undeniably shaped nearly every philosophical, religious, and social construct we now hold. And I often begin with Eve. At least in the Christian tradition, her tale lays the foundation for every subsequent perspective and belief affecting women; the ones, in my opinion, that must change, that can actually invite social justice in new and powerful ways.

The earliest interpreters understood Eve as the tempter of man (thus leading to our endless downfall), as willfully disobeying, listening to the serpent, and thereby escorting evil into perfection and single-handedly securing our banishment from Eden. Clearly: a disadvantage from which we have not been able to regain equilibrium. With this abiding belief system, it’s not hard to make the leap to the realities of injustice. Women have unwittingly borne the consequences of Eve’s choice in a world that tells her she is impossible to trust; a seductress whose curse is to bear any and all pain and suffering – silently and without recourse. (I admit it and apologize: these are broad generalizations. ‘Hope you can go with me just a bit further…)

 

What if we chose to reinterpret Eve’s story, to reframe this applied interpretive lens?

 

What if we could shift the attribution of original sin, shame, and scandal to curiosity, truth-telling, desire, and strength? What if we honored her contribution to civilization, to motherhood, to enabled relationship with the Divine? It changes everything. It tips the scales from disadvantage to advantage. It invites social justice.

 And what if we reinterpreted the snake? In many religious traditions, it holds an honored status as a symbol of wisdom. Instead of being the embodiment of evil and temptation (which then somehow transmuted itself to Eve), what if it was understood as a wise messenger that invites us to listen to our own voice, our own heart, our own intuition – and then to act? It changes everything. It tips the scales from disadvantage to advantage. It invites social justice.

 I could go on and on. The ramifications of textual interpretation – particularly those that are tightly woven into our culture’s subliminal systems and structures – are vast and deep. Women have been and continue to be impacted; yes, harmed. And, as such, men as well. The scales of social justice tip.

 Not a small topic, social justice’s manifestation is profound, weighty, and multi-faceted. But movement and hope occurs when perspectives and beliefs change; when a new telling of an old story occurs. A story that holds social justice as commonplace, affirmed, and desired. A story that tells of women as honored, valued, and esteemed. A story that feels far closer to the Eden we continue to long for. A story that shelters a tree, the fruit of which we all eat liberally. Go on, take a bite…

~Ronna Detrick

Ronna Detrick speaks, writes, and has amazing, RENEGADEconversations about Faith, Feminism, and Telling the Truth. She is compelled by ways in which these three topics weave themselves together in individual lives, relationships, and systems and can’t stop talking about such! Join the conversation! Twitter: @RonnaDetrick, Facebook, and via her blog/newsletter: http://www.RonnaDetrick.com.

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }

Renee Michelle March 16, 2010 at 11:39 AM

Wow, I love your reinterpretation!!!

The “earliest interpreters” sure misunderstood woman, and they inaccurately portrayed us. I believe women’s mistreatment does come from this archaic belief that we are the “tempter of man…..escorting evil” and there by responsible to “bear the pain.”

Yes, yes yes….I love your reinterpretation. The serpent is wise, as are women. We are “curious, truth-tellers”, desirous, full of love, power and strength!! ~Renee Michelle

Reply

Ronna March 16, 2010 at 1:13 PM

Indeed! We are as wise as serpents! ‘Start putting these words together differently (which is allowed!) and all kinds of things change! Thanks, Renee Michelle.

Reply

Deb Owen March 16, 2010 at 11:44 AM

Oh. Eve. Yeah. That one gets me going.

What if we leave the story as is? What if, instead, we take a look at Adam? ;-)

You know, it’s generally the same people who believe that women *are* a weaker vessel (and nowhere in the Bible does it say that), and that it’s man’s “job” to protect and defend and take care of her who also will say it’s all Eve’s fault.

But then, that’s what Adam did, didn’t he?
He didn’t step up and take responsibility for his own actions. He didn’t say, “Yeah. You know? You did tell us not to eat from that particular tree and I did. Sorry.”

He pointed at Eve and blamed her. (Who, in turn, pointed at the devil and blamed him.) They were like three year olds going, “It’s his fault. No, it’s her fault. No, it’s his fault.”

But then, that’s often what we do when it comes to social injustice, isn’t it? “It’s the government’s fault. It’s the men that perpetuate this against women, so let’s just get angry at the men. We can’t get the men on board. It’s too far away. The problem is too big……” and on and on it goes.

Instead of asking, “What *can* I do?” Even if it’s some small action. Even if it’s raising awareness or donating just five dollars or contacting your own government to raise the issue.

All of us getting past just being outraged and moving into just a little action, makes a huge impact.

Love,
deb

P.S. My apologies for ‘posting’ in a comment. Thanks for such a thought-provoking call to action, as always, Ronna. (And thanks for all you do, Desiree! You rock!)

Reply

Ronna March 16, 2010 at 10:42 PM

Genesis 1-3 are, indeed, perplexing and loaded texts that have created much of the construct through which we view our world – regardless of our religious beliefs. I don’t often take the Adam track…not because such isn’t significant and deserving, but because Eve is so often silenced and seen as un-deserving. I SO want to redeem the women’s narratives and wonder about powerful, imaginative ways in which to re-imagine their stories.

That said, you are right, Deb. Adam is a player. And Adam’s descendants (men) have been the predominant players ever since. How we understand his culpability – as well as Eve’s demise – is HUGELY significant.

For me? Plenty of fodder for really amazing conversations!

Reply

Lindsey March 16, 2010 at 12:49 PM

Yes. Just, yes. I have long thought Eve is the first, and essential heroine. Light without knowledge of darkness is meaningless. She invited us to understand the contrasts, and at great risk to herself. I admire her and always will.

Reply

Ronna March 16, 2010 at 10:45 PM

Eve is the first, and essential heroine. I LOVE this, Lindsey. Indeed…she has much to offer, much to teach, much to offer. And I LOVE thinking about all she might say if she had the chance to speak – unguarded, uninhibited, unhindered.

Reply

Rebecca Golightly March 17, 2010 at 3:24 AM

What always kills me about Eve is that she was offered Life, She could have eaten from the other Tree… But she chose Knowledge over Life because she thought it would make her wise. Knowledge alone never makes you wise… Knowledge makes you culpable… not wise. I have so followed in the sister’s footsteps…

Reply

Ronna March 22, 2010 at 4:49 PM

Just now saw your comment, Rebecca. Sorry for the delay. I wonder if following in her footsteps is not all bad. I agree: knowledge is not all that makes us wise; but sometimes curiosity and trusting our heart matters – even when it breaks the rules. And, “interpretation” creates a HUGE category for understanding what those rules were in the first place. Which , for me, just creates more curiosity…

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: